There is no moment like the present. The man who will not execute his resolutions when they are fresh upon him can have no hope from them afterwards: they will be dissipated, lost, and perish in the hurry and scurry of the world, or sunk in the slough of indolence.
~~~~~Maria Edgeworth *Be forewarned that this is going to be a long post. I've held my frustrations within for far too long. *I've waited with bated breath for General Stanley McCrystal's
assessment on the state of Afghanistan. He has been in country long enough to determine what was needed and where. The President was
supposed to make his decision once he had received that particular piece of information from the General he had given the job to. I say "supposed" because now it seems that the "President" is waffling on just what the best decision would be. It remains to be seen whether that would be 'best' for his political career or 'best' for the United States' security as seen from around the world.
From an article in
France 24 on 21, September comes this excerpt...
Fifty-eight percent of Americans now oppose the Afghan war while 39 percent support it, according to a recent CNN/Opinion Research poll.
Obama said in interviews aired on Sunday he wants to wait to determine the proper strategy for U.S. forces in Afghanistan before considering whether more troops should be sent there.
"I just want to make sure that everybody understands that you don't make decisions about resources before you have the strategy ready," he told ABC.
Congressional critics, including his 2008 Republican presidential opponent Senator John McCain, have urged the administration to approve the deployment of more troops immediately, saying any delay puts the lives of troops already in Afghanistan at greater risk.
Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell told CNN on Sunday his party would be supportive of a U.S. troop increase for Afghanistan if it was needed as part of a new strategy but he said he was troubled by the delay in the decision-making.
"We think the time for decision is now," McConnell said.
I have to agree with Kentucky's Senator Mitch McConnell. I, too think that it's time for President Obama to grow a set of cojones and get the ball rolling. Give General McCrystal, who is in charge of all of "Our Guys' and their actions in Afghanistan
EXACTLY what he requested and
do it now! We've had enough time to see that our actions over the last 8 years are making little progress. ISAF and yes, even NATO, will take 1 step forward and 5 steps back every time we lose another villager to those bad guys. We've poured billions of dollars into reconstruction only to have it destroyed by those who oppose our presence and help to their countrymen. Why, you might ask, to continue doing something the same way only to expect a different outcome? That's the definition for insanity! And we've been doing it for 8 years? INSANE!!
Baba Tim at
Free Range International has been living in Afghanistan for over 6 years, and has proven time and time again that living among the villages results in security and progress while providing the local Afghans with jobs that will support their families. Isn't that what a population-centric application of COIN supposed to do? Give the local population security and provide a way for them to live while showing them that their government is much better at taking care of them than the Taliban? Tim's last two post give up a few answers on what to do in Afghanistan.
Part One is here.
Part two is here. Both are must reads, if you are interested in what's going on. Oh, just so you know. Tim has been joined in county by his son, Logan. And he's loving it! That speaks a whole hellva lot about what can be done with his ideas. Just sayin'...
Apparently some of our Special Forces are doing exactly the same thing as Tim.
Read this about one team that has moved into a village of Afghans. What I'd like to know is why is it only the SF that are able to do this? Why is it not
everyone of those units with boots on the ground doing the same thing? If you read Old Blues post from his visit to Bagram,
The Pirates of Pogadishu, you will understand that there are way more of 'Our Guys' deployed to BAF than any other place in country. Again, insanity!
There are many more educated people than I, who have weighed in on this boondoggle we are now calling something other that the
War on Terror. Many of them have been debating their ideas for far too long. This piece
"Afghanistan- No Time To Cut and Run" by Ed Feulner, president of the Heritage Foundation is spot on! And yet, that is what many of those men and women who have the President's ear are calling for. Cut our losses and run back home. To me, that should not be an option! There must be resolve within our elected officials that sit in Washington D.C. to complete this mission. They had it once upon a time. When, where and why did it dissolve into this complete and utter game of one-uppance?
Secretary of Defense, Robert Gates states
his aversion to the withdrawal of our troops. Shouldn't he have more sway with the decisions being made than say...House Speaker, Nancy Pelosi? She's done more
flip flops on Afghanistan than the entire competition of gymnast's at the Olympic Games. And Boy oh Boy! Can she change her mind? Why yes,
yes she can! Here, she states officially and unequivocally she supports the Presidents plans. Of course, that was several months ago. Another flip flop.
While I don't agree completely with this article
found over at Small Wars Journal, there are many good points that can be taken and expounded upon. Small Wars Journal writers are made up of many of those in the "Higher pay grade" bracket. What I'd like to see is more of them actually doing something other than just putting their words in writing. Get off your asses! They, of all men know what it's going to take to make this war go forward instead of backward. Yet, once again... ACTIONS speak louder than words. I want to see some!
I know that all the cogs in the wheels we call our government move slowly, especially the one we call The Big Army. Can't we give them a gigantic push now and then? Oh, and about
those polls they cite repeatedly? I've worked long enough with SPC to know that numbers can be manipulated to show things that support the idea you want to make. How many times do members of the media and of our elected officials use those polls if they show the complete opposite of the point they are tying to make? Yep, you've guessed it. None!
Okay, some might not know the basic history or strategic use of COIN, then read this article by Peter Mansoor. Mr. Mansoor is a professor at
Ohio State University and a retired Army Colonel.
From Baghdad to Kabul: The Historical Roots of U.S. Counterinsurgency Doctrine.There are so many more links that I could give for you to understand this latest delay by the President and all of those in favor of US hightailing it out of Afghanistan is just plain wrong, I could write a fifteen page post. Hopefully y'all are following along with people like
Mudville Gazette,
Blackfive,
Blue and reporters like
David Wood who wrote
this piece from Afghanistan. One of many you should be tracking with regards to the war on terror.
I'll be praying that our President makes the right choices and makes them soon. We've had so many losses of good men who believed in why they were there in Afghanistan. We can't allow them to have given their life for nothing. This is a fight that must be fought to a higher ground.
And that my dear friends, is just my little opinion on this particular part of the War. I reckon my point to this little rant is that I hate to see our country torn apart from within. We are involved in a war that has far reaching effects. One that will not only affect our children, but our grandchildren as well. Part of it goes back to what my parents taught us as children.
Don't ever start a fight, but by golly, you best plan on finishing it...I feel much better now. Thank you for
listening reading.
And so it goes......